These teachings support respectful relations across religious boundaries.
However, the historical issue requires honesty. Classical Muslim jurists differed over the scope of religious freedom and developed legal rulings concerning apostasy and non-Muslim communities that remain subjects of serious debate.
It would therefore be inaccurate to claim that all historical Muslim legal systems recognised religious liberty in precisely the modern sense. The sound response is to acknowledge those debates while emphasizing the Qur’anic principles of sincere belief, justice and responsible religious invitation.
6. What About Women's Rights and Dignity?
Critics frequently argue that certain Islamic teachings concerning women are incompatible with contemporary understandings of equality. This objection should be examined carefully rather than dismissed.
The Qur’an contains significant protections concerning women.
- Surah An-Nisā’ 4:7 recognises women's entitlement to inheritance (imagine grant of share in inheritance to Muslim women more than fourteen hundred years - whereas it was only about 300 years from now that European women got their share in the inheritance)..
- Surah An-Nisā’ 4:19
- The verse prohibits treating women as property to be inherited against their will and commands:
- وَعَاشِرُوهُنَّ بِالْمَعْرُوفِ "Live with them in kindness."
- Surah Al-Aḥzāb 33:35 repeatedly places believing men and women together in its description of spiritual virtues and divine reward.
These teachings challenge any claim that women possess no moral or spiritual standing in Islam. A credible defence of Islam should examine such passages in their language, context and scholarly traditions rather than pretend the difficulties do not exist.
The mistreatment of women must never be excused by appealing vaguely to religion. Equally, genuine differences between religious legal frameworks require careful analysis rather than sweeping insults.
7. But What About Warfare, Slavery and Harsh Punishments?
An honest article must confront these questions because they are among the strongest sources of moral criticism.
- Warfare and the frequently quoted verse 9:5
- Critics sometimes quote Surah At-Tawbah 9:5, which contains a command to fight polytheist opponents, as though it were an unrestricted instruction to kill all non-Muslims.
- Yet the surrounding passage is important.
- Verse 9:4 protects treaties with those who have honoured their agreements.
- Verse 9:6 commands protection for a polytheist seeking safety and requires that he be escorted to a secure place.
These verses demonstrate that the passage contains distinctions concerning treaties, conflict and protection.
- Slavery
- Islam arose in a world where slavery existed across numerous societies.
- The Qur’an encouraged the freeing of enslaved people, identifying emancipation as a righteous act in 90:13. Verse 24:33 also addresses agreements through which enslaved persons could seek freedom and prohibits compelling enslaved women into prostitution.
The Qur’anic encouragement of emancipation offers an important moral direction, while the institution's continued existence presents a legitimate subject for historical and ethical scrutiny.
- Criminal punishments
- Some Islamic legal punishments are also criticized as severe.
- Muslim jurists developed requirements concerning evidence, judicial authority and the prevention of wrongful punishment. But disagreements remain over how particular punishments should be interpreted and applied today.
- A serious discussion must evaluate the relevant texts, legal safeguards, historical applications and present-day human-rights concerns.
- Neither a hostile slogan nor an idealized description of Islamic history can replace thoughtful examination of these difficult subjects.
8. What Do Eminent Scholars Contribute to This Discussion?
Three scholarly approaches are particularly relevant.
- Ibn Kathīr — Human dignity and freedom from coerced belief
- In his tafsīr of 17:70, Ibn Kathīr explains the honour granted to the children of Adam. In his commentary on 2:256, he emphasises that people should not be forced to embrace Islam.
- His explanations provide classical support for the importance of human dignity and meaningful faith.
- Abul A‘lā Maududi — Equality of humanity and the rejection of racial arrogance
- In his detailed commentary on 49:13, Maududi condemns distinctions based on race, colour, nationality and inherited status.
- He explains that the Qur’an rejects the transformation of human diversity into claims of superiority and systems of oppression.
- This is especially relevant when Islam is accused of encouraging contempt for people of other backgrounds.
- Abdullah Yusuf Ali — Justice even when hostility exists
- In his commentary on Surah Al-Mā’idah 5:2 and 5:8, Yusuf Ali emphasises that hatred does not justify retaliation beyond moral limits or unfair treatment.
- His explanation reminds believers that justice is tested not only in peaceful circumstances, but precisely when resentment and conflict make fairness difficult.
These scholars provide important perspectives. They do not resolve every contemporary controversy, nor should their interpretations be represented as unanimous answers to all modern ethical objections.
9. Why Do Some People Nevertheless See Islam as Harsh?
There are several possible reasons.
- Some people encounter Islam primarily through terrorism, sectarian violence, authoritarian governments or discriminatory practices committed by Muslims.
- Others read particular Qur’anic passages without considering their context or the history of interpretation.
- Still others have studied Islamic texts and sincerely disagree with aspects of traditional religious law on ethical grounds.
These are different kinds of criticism, and they should not all be treated alike.
Deliberately portraying all Muslims as dangerous is prejudice. But respectfully questioning a religious law or interpretation is not necessarily hatred. When religion is used to justify corruption, cruelty, intimidation or exploitation, merely declaring that such behaviour is un-Islamic is not enough.
Muslims must demonstrate through conduct, accountability and reform that their professed commitment to justice and compassion is genuine.
10. How Should Muslims Respond to the Accusation?
The Qur’an provides a dignified method of response.
- Surah An-Naḥl 16:125 commands invitation through wisdom and good counsel.
- Surah Al-‘Ankabūt 29:46 instructs believers to engage with the People of the Book in the best manner, subject to its stated qualification concerning wrongdoing.
- Surah Al-Mā’idah 5:8 requires justice even where hostility exists.
Accordingly, the strongest response is not to insult the critic, accuse everyone of malicious intentions or defend every historical act committed by Muslim rulers.
It is to ask what specific teaching the critic objects to, examine its Qur’anic context, study relevant authentic Hadith, compare recognised scholarly interpretations and acknowledge genuine historical difficulties.
Above all, the answer should be visible in conduct.
Let Muslim employers treat workers fairly. Let Muslim families protect the dignity of women and children. Let Muslim communities welcome sincere questions. Let religious scholars discourage hatred. Let charity and humanitarian assistance reach people without making religious conversion a condition.
When conduct reflects the Qur’an's moral demands, it gives substance to arguments that otherwise remain words.
Conclusion: Judge Islam Through Its Teachings—and Hold Muslims Accountable to Them
To describe Islam in its entirety as an ideology “worse than human” is a sweeping accusation that fails to account for the Qur’an's explicit teachings on human dignity, justice, mercy, charity and moral responsibility.
Allah honours the children of Adam (17:70), demands justice even against ourselves (4:135), prohibits hatred from leading to injustice (5:8), commands kindness towards peaceful people of other faiths (60:8), and describes Prophet Muhammad ﷺ as a mercy to the worlds (21:107).
These are not incidental teachings. They form an essential part of Islam's moral framework.
The strongest defence of Islam is both intellectual and practical: explain its teachings accurately, confront difficult questions courageously, and demonstrate its moral principles through the way Muslims treat other human beings.
For Muslims, the challenge is particularly demanding. We cannot expect others to admire Qur’anic justice if they encounter injustice from us. We cannot persuade people of Islamic compassion while showing them cruelty. We cannot condemn prejudice while practising it ourselves.
Let the Qur’an establish the standard, let the authentic Sunnah illuminate that standard, and let our character become its living demonstration.