Why does Allah say they wronged “themselves”?
This is spiritually significant. Sin certainly may hurt other people, but the sinner ultimately damages his own soul. When we lie, cheat, commit adultery, steal, oppress, neglect prayer or disobey Allah, we do not diminish Allah in any way. We damage our own character, conscience and ultimate future.
So Allah says: أَسْرَفُوا عَلَىٰ أَنفُسِهِمْ You have committed excess against yourselves. It is almost compassionate language: you have harmed yourselves—but you can still return.
Scholarly Interpretation
1. Ibn Kathīr: no sin is too great for sincere repentance
Ibn Kathīr calls 39:53 an invitation to all sinners, including unbelievers, to repent and return to Allah. He explicitly says that however great or numerous the sins—even if they were like the foam of the sea—Allah can forgive them when the person genuinely repents.
But Ibn Kathīr adds a crucial qualification: “Allah forgives all sins” does not mean that one may deliberately persist in every sin without repentance.
For example, the Qur’an elsewhere states that dying upon un-repented shirk is not forgiven (4:48). So 39:53 must be read with 39:54, which immediately says:
وَأَنِيبُوا إِلَىٰ رَبِّكُمْ وَأَسْلِمُوا لَهُ “Turn back to your Lord and submit yourselves to Him…”
The sequence therefore is: Do not despair → return to Allah → submit to Him → change your life.
2. Maududi: the verse removes despair, not responsibility
Maududi strongly emphasizes the same point. He interprets the verse as a universal invitation, particularly comforting those who had committed major crimes during the age of ignorance and thought there could no longer be forgiveness for them.
But forgiveness requires turning sincerely toward Allah and obedience to His guidance. The verse does not create permission to continue knowingly in wrongdoing while merely relying upon divine mercy.
This distinction is vital: Hope in Allah is faith. Presuming upon Allah while refusing to change is complacency.
3. Maʿārif al-Qurʾān: one of the Qur’an’s greatest verses of hope
Maʿārif al-Qurʾān records that ʿAbdullāh ibn ʿUmar regarded this as among the Qur’an's strongest verses of hope for sinners. It explains that sincere repentance made before death can erase even extremely serious sins, including disbelief and shirk when a person truly returns to Allah.
This is why Muslim scholars have often treated 39:53 as one of the great āyāt al-rajāʾ — verses of hope.
But does “Allah forgives all sins” include violations of other people's rights?
Here an important distinction must be made. If the sin was purely between a person and Allah, sincere tawbah involves: stopping the sin, regretting it, and sincerely resolving not to return to it.
But if the sin involved another person's rights, repentance also requires rectifying that injustice where possible.
For example:
- If I stole money, repentance requires returning it.
- If I unlawfully took inheritance, I must restore the rightful share.
- If I usurped someone's property, I cannot simply say Astaghfirullah and continue possessing it.
- If I owe someone money, I should repay it.
- If I have wrongfully damaged someone's reputation, some form of rectification may be required depending on the circumstances.
This is particularly important in light of what we have been discussing about halal and haram: Allah's mercy is immense, but repentance does not convert another person's property into ours. Mercy therefore does not abolish justice.
Therefore, this verse should never be understood as: “Do whatever you want because Allah forgives everything.”
The very next verses prevent that misunderstanding:
Connecting this verse with thefollowing verses that complete the loope:
- 39:53 — Do not despair.
- 39:54 — Return and submit to Allah.
- 39:55 — Follow what Allah has revealed.
- 39:56–59 — Do not wait until regret comes too late.
- So Allah's mercy produces transformation, not indifference.
Why this verse is profoundly relevant today
Many people today live between two unhealthy extremes.
- One extreme is: “I have sinned so much that Allah will never forgive me.”
- The other is: “Allah is Merciful, so my sins do not really matter.”
39:53–55 rejects both- To the first person it says: Never despair.
- To the second it says: Return, submit and change before it becomes too late.
Let us elaborate it for better understanding:
1. For someone carrying a sinful past
- A person may have spent years neglecting prayer.
- Another may have committed adultery.
- Another may have been dishonest in business.
- Someone may have abused alcohol or drugs.
- Another may have lived far from religion for decades.
The verse says: Do not allow your past to become a barrier between you and Allah. Remember, Your worst chapter does not have to be your final chapter.'
2. For people who repeatedly fall into the same weakness
- Sometimes a person repents, falls again, repents again and begins thinking: “Allah must be tired of forgiving me.”
- That is projecting human limitations onto Allah.
- The proper response is not to become comfortable with sin but to keep returning sincerely while fighting the weakness.
- Failure should produce renewed tawbah—not despair.
3. For older people who think it is too late
This verse is particularly powerful late in life.
- Someone may think: “I wasted forty years.”
- The Qur’an does not say: “You should have come earlier, therefore the door is closed.”
- It says: لَا تَقْنَطُوا مِن رَّحْمَةِ اللَّهِ “Do not despair of Allah’s mercy.”
As long as genuine repentance remains possible, the believer should return.
4. For a society obsessed with permanent condemnation
Modern culture can sometimes declare a person permanently defined by the worst thing he ever did.
The Qur’anic worldview is different.
- Wrongdoing must be acknowledged.
- Victims' rights must be protected.
- Justice must be done.
But human beings can morally transform. Islam leaves room for repentance because without the possibility of moral rehabilitation there would be little incentive for the wrongdoer to change.
5. For those trapped by shame
There is an important difference between guilt and despair.
- Healthy guilt says: “I did something wrong; I must return to Allah.”
- Despair says: “I am beyond Allah’s mercy.”
The first can lead to repentance - The second can push someone further into sin.
That is precisely why Satan may benefit from both the original sin and the despair that follows it.
39:53 breaks that cycle. The astonishing tenderness of “O My servants” Perhaps the most moving feature of the verse is that Allah does not say: “O criminals.” - Instead He says: يَا عِبَادِي “O My servants.”
We must understand that after: sin, disobedience, neglect, and excess, the relationship has not been closed. It is almost as though the verse says: You may have moved far away from Me, but you have not moved beyond My mercy.
How should we act upon 39:53?
The verse should lead not merely to emotional comfort but to tawbah. A practical repentance involves:
- Recognize the wrong — stop justifying it.
- Regret it sincerely — allow conscience to awaken.
- Stop the sin.
- Ask Allah for forgiveness.
- Resolve sincerely not to return.
- If another person's rights were violated, restore them.
- Thereafter, Follow the wrong with good deeds.
This connects beautifully with 25:70, where Allah says that for those who repent, believe and do righteous deeds, He can even replace their evil deeds with good deeds. That is more than forgiveness. It is transformation.
Why despair itself is spiritually dangerous
When one has sinned, one may generally get into depression and a state of despair that whether his repentance will work or not. In that state:
- Despair says: “My sin is greater than Allah's mercy.”
- But 39:53 tells us that this is fundamentally wrong.
- No matter how large the sin appears from the human side, Allah's forgiveness is greater.
But the verse does not tell us to underestimate sin. It tells us never to underestimate Allah.
The central lesson
Surah Az-Zumar 39:53 does not teach: “Your sins do not matter.” - rather it teaches something far more powerful: “Your sins matter—but they are never greater than Allah’s mercy when you sincerely return to Him.”
And when read together with verses 54–55, the complete message becomes: